Histogram feature suggestion
Posted: November 20th, 2010, 3:46 pm
I've seen a lot of histograms lately and I was thinking what would make the histograms work even better:
1) PWP is not bad in this department, but it's often v. difficult to detect and interpret the fully blown pixel column on the histogram because it's a thin line (1px wide) and it's hard to see and relate its height to the area of the rest of the histogram. Since blown (and blocked) pixels are of special importance, would it make sens to emphasize them somewhat (e.g. make the 0% and the 100% histogram bins 2 pixel wide or have a numerical display of X% pixels blown/blocked at each end of the scale?).
2) Is is difficult to graphically link the histogram range with the pixels that contributed to it? What I would find useful is e.g. being able to drag the range on a histogram and have PWP highlight/blink the corresponding range of pixels in the input image (or preview). This is kind of reverse of Curves transformation where you can click on the image and display the pixel value on the histogram as a red line (which is even better implemented in AS where holding shift and dragging the mouse, highlights the range of the 'roughness' values below the histogram).
1) PWP is not bad in this department, but it's often v. difficult to detect and interpret the fully blown pixel column on the histogram because it's a thin line (1px wide) and it's hard to see and relate its height to the area of the rest of the histogram. Since blown (and blocked) pixels are of special importance, would it make sens to emphasize them somewhat (e.g. make the 0% and the 100% histogram bins 2 pixel wide or have a numerical display of X% pixels blown/blocked at each end of the scale?).
2) Is is difficult to graphically link the histogram range with the pixels that contributed to it? What I would find useful is e.g. being able to drag the range on a histogram and have PWP highlight/blink the corresponding range of pixels in the input image (or preview). This is kind of reverse of Curves transformation where you can click on the image and display the pixel value on the histogram as a red line (which is even better implemented in AS where holding shift and dragging the mouse, highlights the range of the 'roughness' values below the histogram).